Welcome to Comic Book Galaxy.

The ADD Blog by Alan David Doane. Chris Allen Online Reviews of comics and graphic novels. Commentary about the artform and industry of comics. Get back to the main page.

CBG SATELLITES

The ADD Blog by Alan David Doane
Chris Allen Online by Christopher Allen
Ramble On by Rob Vollmar
A Criminal Blog by Alan David Doane
Kochalkaholic! by Alan David Doane



Hard-to-find sodas shipped directly to your door! Sodafinder.com.

Visit Blinding Force Productions for quality design work.



PLEASE SUPPORT COMIC BOOK GALAXY BY VISITING OUR SPONSORS

Elk's Run - Bumper Edition
Written by J.H. Fialkov
Art by Noel Tuazon
Colors by Scott A. Keating
Published by Speakeasy Comics; $7.99 USD

I missed out on Elk's Run #1-3 in the original floppy editions published by Hoarse and Buggy in 2004. But, judging by Joshua Fialkov's letter to his readers (printed on the final page of this collection), Elk's Run flew under the radar of most comic book readers, so I'm not alone. But, again like most of those who have finally become aware of the existence of Elk's Run, I'm pleased to have finally discovered it, and dismayed that such a quality piece of work has eluded the attention of so many readers thus far. So far, Elk's Run has delivered the goods - characters to care about, a great story that keeps the pages turning, artwork that draws the reader into that story, and colouring that sets the mood beautifully.

Elk's Run is set in Elk's Ridge, West Virginia, a little town cut off from civilization by choice, not merely by circumstances. While the story is told from several points of view, the focus is on the Kohler family - John, Sara, and their son, John Jr. John Kohler is one of a group of Vietnam veterans settled in Elk's Ridge after returning home from the war. We're told that their benefactor, who hasn't appeared in the story thus far (although I have a feeling he may show up in future issues) had read Utopia, and Elk's Ridge is his attempt to build his own personal Utopia. He provides the townsfolk with every necessity, and everything appears to be going along smoothly until one of the town's teenagers is run over by a resident who is trying to "escape."

...and that's where everything hits the fan. Hardly surprisingly, Elk's Ridge is Utopia no longer; the seeds of conflict between families, between generations, and between Elk's Ridge and the outside world have been sown, and we can only wait for future issues to find out where this story will take us. So far, the creators have built a world for their characters that, despite the fantastic premise, is so tightly constructed and well-plotted as to be entirely believable. Noel Tuazon's brushwork is loose and suggestive rather than detailed and meticulous, yet characters are well-drawn, and the reader's imagination fills in the blanks left in the sketchy backgrounds. Scott Keating's colors, and his pallette of rich reds, browns, and greens provide atmosphere and mood, with a particularly noteworthy mastery of lighting in a number of scenes. Especially effective are the dinner table scenes in the Kohler house, which provide real insight about this family's relationships without having to use a lot of words to tell the story. As for the plot itself, backstory and flashbacks are skillfully woven in to the main narrative, and the artwork on the Vietnam flashback sequence in Chapter 2 shows that in the hands of a capable artist, graphic detail is unnecessary to portray the horrors of war.

Finally, a note on presentation - this book, apart from the top-notch story contained within its covers, also provides even more bang for the buck in the "extras" that are included. There's a cover gallery, displaying Datsun Tran's great work on #1-3 and the 4th issue preview, there's a two-page "Plot to Page" feature written by editor Jason Rodriguez, the original proposal for the series, and finally, Scott Keating provides a two-page coloring tutorial, detailing how he transformed Noel Tuazon's inking into the finished product we see. This kind of attention to detail shown by Speakeasy says a lot for the care and attention they put into the books they produce.

All in all, I can't recommend this book highly enough, and the great thing is, there are still five issues left. In his introduction, Steve Niles writes, "I know we're less than halfway there, but I for one can't wait to see where Joshua, Noel and Keating take us next." And I couldn't agree more. Issue #4 is due to appear on store shelves at the end of November, and I'll certainly be keeping an eye out for it.

-- Jim Witt

Send review copies to:
Jim Witt
3311 Springvale Crt.
Burlington, Ontario, Canada
L7M 3Y6

Discuss this review on the Comic Book Galaxy Forum!


Google
Search WWW Search Comic Book Galaxy


[COMIC BOOK GALAXY IS COPYRIGHT (C) 2006 BY COMIC BOOK GALAXY PARTNERS; ALL RIGHTS RESERVED]