[ Message Board · Trouble with Comics · Reviews · Essays · Interviews · Audio Interviews · Facebook · writeblog · A Criminal Blog · Kochalkaholic · FAQ · E-Mail ]

Monday, March 23, 2009

Baxter Building Your Collection -- Tom Spurgeon has posted a terrific piece on alternatives to buying current serialized comic books. A couple of thoughts.

My first thought reading the piece was that when Frank Santoro recommends reading old issues of Marvel/Epic's Coyote, I suspect he is thinking of the sublimely illustrated first batch of issues drawn by Steve Leialoha. Then I started thinking about buying that series, which was on printed on something then referred to as "Baxter Paper," which got me to thinking about Tom's reference to old comics as a "tidal wave of decaying paper," which is not a characterization I'd argue with -- the deterioration of old comics is one reason I generally eschew buying them -- but that brings me back to Baxter Paper.

If you weren't there in the 1980s you probably don't remember what a big deal this particular paper stock was -- but it's become significant to me in recent years specifically because it doesn't seem to be decaying like regular newsprint comics of the same vintage.

I recently snapped up DC's six-issue New Gods special edition reprints for less than cover price. Sure, the hardcover Jack Kirby's Fourth World Omnibus editions are great (if pricey, at 50 bucks a pop for four volumes), but I've been wanting a nice reprint of just the New Gods stories by themselves, and the Baxter Paper reprints fit the bill. Even after 25 years or so, the paper remains white and sturdy, the colours vibrant and bold, and far more pleasurable to me to read and experience than either the hardcovers or the original, decaying comics.

Both Marvel and DC published a lot of Baxter Paper projects -- Thriller, mentioned by Tom in the piece linked above, was another one (and well worth seeking out) -- and if, like me, you hate spending lots of money on flimsy old newsprint comics slowly turning into smelly cornflakes, then the Baxter Paper comics of the 1980s are a great place to look for some great reading. Here are seven titles you should be able to find cheap:

* Doctor Strange Classics -- Four double-sized issues collecting Lee and Ditko Dr. Strange stories.

* Thriller -- Robert Loren Fleming and Trevor Von Eeden's weird, wild adventure comic. Thrills somewhere between Lost and Twin Peaks.

* Captain America Special Edition -- I think there were three issues of this, vibrantly reprinting Jim Steranko's hyper-masculine, psychedelic Cap stories.

* Conan Special Edition: Red Nails -- Lacking the undesirable "remastering" of Dark Horse's recent Conan Marvel-era reprints, this double-sized one-shot has wall-to-wall gorgeous Barry Windsor-Smith art on probably the most acclaimed story of the Thomas/BWS Conan run.

* Deadman -- Seven issues collecting the gorgeous, mostly Neal Adams-drawn stories of ghostly circus performer Boston Brand and his afterlife adventures.

* Warlock Special Edition -- I forget if there were five or six of these, but they gathered together all the Jim Starlin Warlock stories, with their weird ideas and the stunning, guest-star-spangled two-part conclusion that originally crossed over between double-sized annuals of Marvel Two-in-One and Marvel Team-Up.

* The Elektra Saga -- Four issues resequencing Miller and Janson's most notable Daredevil storyline from its very beginning to its then-definitive end.

In keeping with the spirit of what Tom is talking about in his piece, these should all be available for not much more than cover price. I don't know why these and the other Baxter Paper books aren't more sought-after (and I'm not trying to start a run on the bank, believe me -- I want them for my collection much more than I want them for yours!), but given the quality of many of the titles, the way the paper they're printed on has held up over the years, how many of them were printed and how they're largely available dirt-cheap (I guess those last two points might be connected), I felt like it would be wrong not to point out to you how many great comics are out there not decaying and waiting to be rediscovered. If, like me, you lack the Collector Gene and just want to read the stories with good reproduction and without spending a fortune, with the Baxter Paper books, if you know what you're looking for, you can't go wrong.

The challenge lies in that phrase, "if you know what you're looking for." None of the Baxter Paper titles had the phrase "Baxter Paper" in the actual name of the book, but look for reprints from Marvel and DC circa 1984-1987, frequently slugged "Special Edition," almost always double-sized, and make sure you get a look at the insides to see if the paper is still white and the colours still vibrant and bold.

Just in the past year I've been seeking these books out, and reimmersing myself in the Conan: Red Nails and Kirby New Gods books -- for less than two bucks per issue -- has provided some of the most visceral comics-reading thrills I've had in a long time. Mister Baxter, whoever you were, I thank you.



Blogger Mikester said...

Amusingly, Marvel rereleased the Warlock reprint series during the whole Infinity Gauntlet etc. brouhaha...I don't have the second version right in front of me, but it had different covers and it may have been on different (slicker?) paper. I don't recall exactly, though I know I have them at the shop.

I remember when Marvel started with these high end reprints, the complaint was at the time that Marvel was simply trying to crowd other publishers off the rack. There was quite the hue and cry, but it's nice to have some of these books now.

There's also a Micronauts "Special Edition" series reprinting some nice Michael Golden work that's worth seeking out.

23 March, 2009 03:29  
Blogger Alan David Doane said...

Oh, man, Mike, I totally forgot about Micronauts! You're right. There's another Baxter series to seek out. Thanks!

23 March, 2009 03:32  
Blogger Johnny B said...

I'd like to take this opportunity to direct anyone curious about Thriller to this website I created about six years ago, badly in need of revamping but no less informative.

23 March, 2009 08:21  
Blogger N said...

I'm pretty sure those are Lee and Ditko Dr. Strange stories in the Classics reprints, not Lee and Kirby. :)


23 March, 2009 18:49  
Blogger Alan David Doane said...

And Neil gets a NO-PRIZE!

What a super screw-up...and who better to fix it, True Believers, than Doc's #1 fan?

Thanks, Neil! :-)

23 March, 2009 19:12  
Blogger Marc said...

Great post, Alan. Thanks. Those Lee/Ditko Dr. Strange books are exactly what I've been looking for since I don't want to spend $50 on the Masterworks hardcover. A few other Baxter classics that occurred to me as I was reading your post were: Spiderman vs. Wolverine (just re-read this recently and the story holds up surprisingly well), the Saga of Ra's al Ghul collecting a good run of Neal Adams Batman books and various issues of Marvel Fanfare.

23 March, 2009 20:15  
Blogger bob said...

DC's "Baxter" reprint line actually ran almost monthly, with a few small gaps and one big gap, for about 5 years from 1983 to 1988 (at which time trade paperbacks were becoming more common). I think these are all of them, in published order.

Green Lantern Green Arrow 1-7
Manhunter 1
New Gods 1-6
Man-Bat 1
Immortal Dr. Fate 1-3
[one month gap]
Deadman 1-7
Shadow of the Batman 1-5
[two month gap]
Roots of the Swamp Thing 1-5
[thirteen month gap]
Saga of Ra's Al Ghul 1-4
Wrath of the Spectre 1-4
[one month gap]
Best of the Brave and the Bold 1-6

I think everything except the Doctor Fate and maybe the Man-Bat were later available in tradepaperbacks or hardcovers.

23 March, 2009 20:53  
Blogger Alan David Doane said...


Marvel Fanfare was printed on cover stock, not Baxter Paper...it was slick and shiny. To me one of the strengths of the Baster stock is that it was sturdy but not as shiny as the Fanfare stock, which resulted in a more garish look to the art. Glad you liked the post, though -- thanks for your comments!


Wow! That list is extremely helpful, thank you! I had almost all of those back when they originally came out, and I can't believe how many of them I forgot. I also can't believe how perfect the choices were. If only today's superhero comics editors were as picky about what does or does not constitute a true classic...

24 March, 2009 02:12  
Blogger ~P~ said...

Also, another BAXTER reprint for the Doctor Strange fans was the DOCTOR STRANGE Special Edition which reprinted the Steve Englehart / Frank Brunner issues with the villainous SILVER DAGGER.

(Dr. Strange; Master of the Mystic Arts # 1 - 5 iirc)

Marvel had a bunch of those "Special Edition" reprints as well as the "Classics" reprint series.
Warlock was one of those with the "Classics".

If I'm not misremembering;
"Special Edition" meant it was a "book-length" single issue collecting one major story "arc".

"Classics" were 3 or 4 issue mini-series collecting more than one arc of older material.

I'd have to go up to my "Sanctum" to check, but I'm fairly sure that's right.

Sanctum Sanctorum Comix

24 March, 2009 08:18  

Post a Comment

<< Home





Banks are regarded the best option for making a safe investments as well as having world wide accepted creditcard. People are not only facilitated by loans but also provided debt management consolidation by the leading banks. Students can also get loans as well as apply for student loan consolidation. At the same time high flying insurance companies also contribute to the any one’s life through offering different plans of life, health and dental insurance. Along insurance of life one can also enhance its home security through installing latest home security systems.

This page is powered by ADD.